Top artists in the collection:
| Winslow Homer | American, 1836-1910 | 9 artworks |
| Maurice Prendergast | Canadian, 1858-1924 | 6 artworks |
| John Singer Sargent | American, 1856-1925 | 4 artworks |
| Thomas Eakins | American, 1844-1916 | 3 artworks |
| Eastman Johnson | American, 1824-1906 | 3 artworks |
| John La Farge | American, 1835-1910 | 3 artworks |
| John Twachtman | American, 1853-1902 (Impressionist) | 3 artworks |
| George Wesley Bellows | American, 1882-1925 (Ashcan) | 2 artworks |
| Theodore Robinson | American, 1852-1896 | 2 artworks |
| Frederick Childe Hassam | American, 1859-1935 (Impressionist) | 2 artworks |
| Thomas Chambers | English, 1808-1866 | 2 artworks |
The Athenaeum has no exhibitions on record for this museum. Exhibition records can be added for this museum here.