Top artists in the collection:
| Peter Paul Rubens | Belgian, 1577-1640 (Baroque) | 23 artworks |
| Lucas Cranach the Elder | German, 1472-1553 (High Renaissance) | 18 artworks |
| Albrecht Dürer | German, 1471-1528 (Northern Renaissance) | 15 artworks |
| Rembrandt van Rijn | Dutch, 1606-1669 (Dutch Golden Age) | 11 artworks |
| Fra Angelico | Italian, 1387-1455 (Early Renaissance) | 8 artworks |
| Titian | Italian, 1485-1576 (High Renaissance) | 8 artworks |
| Raphael | Italian, 1483-1520 (High Renaissance) | 6 artworks |
| Bartolomé Esteban Murillo | Spanish, 1617-1682 (Baroque) | 5 artworks |
| Domenico Ghirlandaio | Italian, 1449-1494 (Early Renaissance) | 4 artworks |
| Nicolas Poussin | French, 1594-1665 (Classicist) | 4 artworks |
| Fra Filippo Lippi | Italian, 1406-1469 (Early Renaissance) | 4 artworks |
The Athenaeum has no exhibitions on record for this museum. Exhibition records can be added for this museum here.