Top artists in the collection:
| Gilbert Stuart | American, 1755-1828 | 2 artworks |
| Winslow Homer | American, 1836-1910 | 2 artworks |
| John Sloan | American, 1871-1951 (Ashcan) | 2 artworks |
| John Smibert | Scottish, 1688-1751 | 2 artworks |
| Rockwell Kent | American, 1882-1971 | 1 artworks |
| William Stanley Haseltine | American, 1835-1900 (Hudson River School) | 1 artworks |
| Thomas Worthington Whittredge | American, 1820-1910 | 1 artworks |
| Alexander Charles Stuart | Scottish, 1831-1898 | 1 artworks |
| Charles Codman | American, 1800-1842 | 1 artworks |
| Louis Remy Mignot | American, 1831-1870 | 1 artworks |
| Nathaniel Smibert | American, 1735-1756 | 1 artworks |
The Athenaeum has no exhibitions on record for this museum. Exhibition records can be added for this museum here.